Unpacking New York’s Implied Consent Law

Last updated on January 23, 2024

When driving on any road, it’s crucial for individuals to be aware of the laws that govern their conduct. One of the most significant, yet often misunderstood, is New York’s implied consent law. This law has far-reaching implications for anyone who gets behind the wheel and could profoundly affect you if you are charged with a DWI. Understanding the ins and outs of the implied consent law is vital. It not only helps you make informed decisions if you are ever suspected of DWI, but it also prepares you to handle the legal challenges that could arise from a refusal to take the chemical test. 

If you have been charged with a DWI in New York, top-rated Long Island DWI attorney Jason Bassett is here to provide the skilled representation and clear guidance you need during this critical time. Jason Bassett has a deep understanding of New York DWI laws and a proven track record of successfully defending clients in situations similar to yours. He can walk you through the complexities of the implied consent law alongside the potential costs of a DWI conviction in addition to providing detailed information about the differences between DWI and DUI charges in New York. He can help you navigate the complexities of the implied consent law, formulate a strong defense strategy, and protect your rights every step of the way. 

The sooner you act, the more options you’ll have for building a robust defense. Schedule a consultation with Jason Bassett today and gain the peace of mind that comes from knowing you have a seasoned DWI attorney in your corner. To learn more about how we can help. call the Law Offices of Jason Bassett, P.C. at (631) 259-6060.

Experienced Long Island DWI Attorney Jason Bassett Discusses the Implied Consent Law

The implied consent law in New York is a legal statute that requires motorists within the state to consent to sobriety testing if they are arrested on suspicion of driving while intoxicated (DWI) or driving under the influence (DUI). Under this law, the act of operating a vehicle while on a public road serves as implied consent to submit to a chemical test to determine the driver’s blood alcohol content (BAC) level.

The primary purpose of the implied consent law is to deter drunk driving and enhance road safety. By making chemical testing a condition of driving, the law aims to discourage individuals from getting behind the wheel while under the influence of alcohol or drugs.

Implied consent laws also serve to aid law enforcement and prosecutors in obtaining evidence of a driver’s impairment. This evidence can be crucial in DUI/DWI cases, helping to secure convictions and enforce penalties that further serve as a deterrent to drunk driving.

It’s important to note, however, that while the implied consent law facilitates the testing process, it doesn’t eliminate a driver’s legal rights. Those suspected of drunk driving are still entitled to legal representation and the right to defend themselves in court.

When Does the Implied Consent Law Apply in New York?

If you are operating a motor vehicle in New York, you have implicitly agreed to abide by the state’s implied consent law. This agreement holds regardless of where your driver’s license was issued. So, even if you’re just passing through, or you’re a tourist, if you’re a driver on the road in New York, the implied consent law applies to you.

Implied Consent in DWI Investigations

Implied consent plays a significant role in the process of DWI investigations in New York. It covers everything from the moment an officer suspects a driver may be impaired to the administration of chemical tests. Let’s look at this process in detail.

Traffic Stops and Suspicion of DWI

A DWI investigation typically begins with a traffic stop. Law enforcement officers might pull a vehicle over for a variety of reasons – it could be for a minor traffic violation, erratic driving behavior, or a routine DWI checkpoint. If an officer suspects that the driver is under the influence of alcohol or drugs due to observed signs of impairment, this can lead to a DWI investigation.

During the traffic stop, the officer will observe the driver for signs of impairment. This might include the smell of alcohol, slurred speech, bloodshot eyes, or difficulty retrieving documents like a driver’s license or vehicle registration. These observations can provide the reasonable grounds needed to initiate a DWI investigation.

Standardized Field Sobriety Tests

If an officer suspects that a driver is impaired, they may ask the driver to perform field sobriety tests. These are physical tests designed to assess a driver’s level of impairment, such as the horizontal gaze nystagmus (HGN) test, the walk-and-turn test, and the one-leg stand test. These tests can provide additional evidence of impairment and justify the administration of chemical tests under the implied consent law. It is important to note that doing the field sobriety test is not covered under the implied consent law in New York and drivers have no legal obligation to perform these tests.

Types of Chemical Tests

If an officer has reasonable grounds to believe a driver is impaired, they can request the driver to submit to a chemical test under the implied consent law. These tests typically involve testing the driver’s blood, breath, urine, or saliva to determine the level of alcohol or drugs in the driver’s system.

The Role of Implied Consent in Breathalyzer Tests

Under New York’s implied consent law, if an officer requests a breathalyzer test (a type of chemical test), the driver is expected to comply. The breathalyzer device measures the amount of alcohol in the driver’s breath, which can be used to estimate the blood alcohol concentration (BAC). Refusal to take a breathalyzer test can lead to immediate license suspension and other penalties, regardless of whether the driver was actually impaired. This is one of the crucial aspects of the implied consent law – the automatic consequences that arise from a refusal to submit to testing.

Implied Consent in DWI Investigations Description
Traffic Stops and Suspicion of DWI DWI investigations often start with a traffic stop based on observed signs of impairment, such as alcohol smell or slurred speech.
Standardized Field Sobriety Tests Officers may conduct field sobriety tests to assess impairment, but drivers are not legally obligated to perform these tests.
Types of Chemical Tests Chemical tests (blood, breath, urine, or saliva) may be administered to determine alcohol or drug levels in the driver’s system.
Implied Consent in Breathalyzer Tests Drivers are expected to comply with breathalyzer tests when requested; refusal can lead to license suspension and penalties.

Consequences for Refusing a Chemical Test Under Implied Consent

While the implied consent law in New York does require drivers to submit to chemical testing when lawfully arrested for suspected drunk driving, you do have the right to refuse these tests. However, refusal comes with serious consequences that can have a lasting impact on your driving privileges. 

In New York, if you refuse to take a chemical test (breath, blood, urine, or saliva), your driver’s license can be immediately suspended. This suspension is automatic and happens right at the moment of your refusal. The officer will confiscate your driver’s license and issue a temporary driving permit that’s valid until your hearing on the refusal.

Following a Refusal Hearing at the DMV, your ability to gain a conditional license can be revoked if the suspension is upheld. The duration of the suspension of your driving privileges depends on your history of refusals and convictions for drunk driving. 

  • For a first-time refusal, your license will be revoked for at least one year and you may be required to pay a $500 fine. 
  • If you’ve refused a chemical test before, or if you’ve been convicted of a DWI/DUI in the past five years, the revocation period increases to at least 18 months with a fine of $750.

If you refuse chemical testing multiple times, or if you have a previous DWI conviction, you could face not only lengthier revocation periods but also the possibility of permanently losing your driving privileges in New York. The state takes a hard stance against repeat offenders, and the penalties reflect that philosophy.

Choosing whether or not to submit to a breathalyzer or other forms of chemical testing after a DWI/DUI arrest can be a challenging decision. A failed test would most likely lead to a conviction for drunk driving. Conversely, a refusal could potentially lessen the amount of evidence against you, but it comes with its own set of consequences.

It’s also important to note that even without a definitive Blood Alcohol Content (BAC) test result, you can still be charged and potentially found guilty of drunk driving. According to New York law, your decision to not submit to a test can be used as evidence against you during DWI/DUI criminal proceedings. This means that refusal doesn’t necessarily protect you from a conviction.

In such a complex situation, understanding the various risks and repercussions is crucial in making the most informed decision. 

The Chemical Tests Under Implied Consent

Following an arrest for suspected DUI/DWI in New York, law enforcement may administer several types of chemical tests to determine the level of alcohol or drugs in your system. This falls under the purview of the implied consent law. Here’s what you should know about these tests.

Breath Test

A breath test, often administered using a device known as a breathalyzer, is the most common type of test used in DUI/DWI investigations. The device measures the amount of alcohol in your breath, which is then used to estimate your blood alcohol concentration (BAC). Breath tests are non-invasive and provide quick results, but they must be administered correctly to ensure accurate results.

Blood Test

A blood test provides the most accurate measurement of the amount of alcohol or drugs in the driver’s system. This test involves drawing a sample of blood and sending it to a lab for analysis. While this test is more invasive and results take longer to obtain, its accuracy makes it a powerful piece of evidence in court. However, because it is more invasive, it is typically used in serious cases, such as those involving accidents or injuries.

Urine Test

A urine test may be used to detect the presence of alcohol and drugs in a driver’s system. This test is less common for alcohol detection as it’s considered less accurate than breath and blood tests. However, it can be more effective in detecting the presence of certain drugs. Like the blood test, a urine test involves sending the sample to a lab for analysis, so results are not immediately available.

Limited Grounds to Refuse Chemical Testing

While the implied consent law in New York generally requires drivers to submit to chemical testing when lawfully arrested for a DWI, there are very limited grounds under which a driver can refuse such a test without facing penalties. Here, we will cover these exceptions.

Medical Inability to Take the Test

In some cases, a medical condition may prevent a driver from being able to take a certain type of chemical test. For example, a person with a respiratory condition may be unable to provide a sufficient breath sample for a breathalyzer test. In such cases, the driver should inform the officer of their medical condition. The officer may then decide to administer a different type of test.

No Miranda/Constitutional Rights to Refuse

Contrary to what some people believe, there is no constitutional or Miranda right to refuse a chemical test under the implied consent law. The U.S. Supreme Court has upheld the constitutionality of implied consent laws, stating that driving is a privilege that comes with certain conditions. Therefore, a refusal cannot be justified on the basis that the driver was not read their Miranda rights before being asked to submit to a test.

Confusion about Consent is Not Grounds

Another common misconception is that a driver can refuse a test because they were confused or did not understand what was being asked of them. However, confusion or misunderstanding about the implied consent law is generally not considered a valid reason to refuse a test. In New York, when a driver is asked to submit to a chemical test, the officer is required to inform them of the consequences of refusal. Therefore, a lack of understanding is unlikely to be accepted as a valid reason for refusal.

Requesting an Additional Chemical Test

In some cases, after law enforcement has administered a chemical test, a driver may wish to have an additional test performed. This can be an important part of building a defense in a DWI case. Here’s what you should know.

Right to Additional Test at Own Expense

In New York, if you have been arrested for a DWI and have undergone a chemical test administered by law enforcement, you have the right to request an additional independent test. This test is to be performed by a medical professional of your choosing and is at your own expense. This additional test can provide a second set of results that may be used in your defense.

Must be Done Promptly after Initial Test

If you choose to have an additional test performed, it’s important to understand that this test must be done promptly after the initial test. This is because the level of alcohol or drugs in your system can change over time. The more time that passes between the two tests, the less reliable the comparison between the results will be.

Results Can be Used to Challenge Initial Test

The results of an independent test can be used in court to challenge the accuracy of the initial test performed by law enforcement. For example, if the independent test shows a significantly lower level of alcohol or drugs in your system than the initial test, this could raise questions about the accuracy of the initial test or the procedures used to administer it. However, it’s important to note that the results of an independent test can also potentially strengthen the prosecution’s case if they are consistent with the results of the initial test.

Hearings and Suspension Appeals Related to Chemical Test Refusal

If your license has been suspended due to refusing a chemical test under New York’s implied consent law, there are specific procedures to challenge this suspension. It’s important to understand these steps, as well as the limited grounds on which an appeal can be made.

Hearings to Challenge License Suspension

After a refusal to submit to a chemical test, a hearing will be scheduled in the DMV. This hearing is separate from any criminal proceedings related to a DWI charge. At the hearing, the judge will consider whether the police officer had reasonable grounds to believe you were driving under the influence, whether you were lawfully arrested, whether you were informed of the consequences of refusal, and whether you actually refused the test.

Limited Grounds for Appeal

The grounds on which you can appeal a suspension for refusing a chemical test are limited. Generally, you would need to demonstrate that the officer did not have reasonable grounds to believe you were driving under the influence and that your arrest was unlawful.

Procedures and Time Limits

It’s crucial to act promptly when seeking to challenge a license suspension for refusing a chemical test. In New York, you have a limited amount of time to request a hearing after your arrest. If you miss this deadline, you could lose your right to a hearing and your license will be suspended. It’s strongly recommended to work with a lawyer who is familiar with DWI laws and procedures to ensure that your rights are protected.

Other Consequences of Refusing a Chemical Test

Refusing a chemical test in New York under the implied consent law can have significant consequences beyond immediate license suspension. The refusal can impact your DWI case and potentially lead to increased charges or penalties. Here’s a closer look at these consequences.

Refusal Can Be Used as Evidence in DWI Case

If you refuse a chemical test, that refusal can be used as evidence against you in a DWI case. The prosecution may argue that your refusal indicates consciousness of guilt, suggesting that you refused the test because you knew you were impaired. This can make it more difficult to defend against a DWI charge.

Possibility of Increased Charges/Penalties

In addition to being used as evidence against you, a refusal can also lead to increased charges or penalties. If you are convicted of a DWI, the fact that you refused a chemical test could be considered an aggravating factor, leading to a harsher sentence. This might include a longer license suspension, higher fines, or even a longer jail sentence. Furthermore, a refusal can lead to a separate charge of “refusal to submit to a chemical test,” which carries its own penalties.

How an Experienced Long Island DWI Attorney Can Help

A skilled Long Island DWI attorney can play a crucial role in helping individuals charged with a DWI understand the nuances of the implied consent law in New York. Here are some key ways an attorney can assist:

Clarifying Legal Rights and Procedures

A skilled attorney can provide clear explanations about an individual’s rights under the implied consent law, the procedures involved, and the potential consequences of refusing a chemical test. They can help clients understand why they might be asked to submit to a chemical test, what the results could mean for their case, and what options they have if they choose to refuse the test.

Formulating a Defense Strategy

If a client has refused a chemical test, a seasoned DWI attorney can help them understand the potential legal repercussions and assist in formulating a defense strategy that considers this refusal. The attorney can thoroughly analyze the case, identify any potential weaknesses in the prosecution’s evidence, and construct a strong defense strategy accordingly.

Preparing for Refusal Hearings

A skilled attorney can help ensure clients are prepared for hearings related to license suspensions following a chemical test refusal. They can guide clients through what to expect at the hearing, the types of questions they might be asked, and the best way to present their case. Additionally, an experienced Long Island DWI attorney can also assist throughout the process of defending against the DWI charge itself and build a strong strategy tailored to their client’s case.

Assisting with Appeals

If the initial hearing does not go favorably, an attorney can assist with the appeal process. They can help clients understand the limited grounds on which they can appeal and navigate the strict procedural timelines that apply to ensure all deadlines are met.

A DWI charge can have serious consequences. A skilled Long Island DWI attorney can help individuals fully understand the charges against them, provide strong legal advocacy, and assist clients in navigating the complex DWI laws in New York.

Call Top-Rated Long Island DWI Attorney Jason Bassett Today

If you or a loved one has been charged with a DWI on Long Island, New York, and are facing legal issues regarding the implied consent law, seek legal guidance from a seasoned professional. Jason Bassett, a top-rated Long Island DWI attorney, is here to provide the experienced legal advice and representation that you need.

With extensive knowledge and experience in New York DWI law, Attorney Bassett can help you understand your rights, the charges against you, and the complexities of the implied consent law. He can provide crucial guidance, build a strong defense strategy tailored to your unique circumstances, and stand by your side throughout the entire legal process. The consequences of a DWI charge can be severe, but with the right legal support, you can fight for the best possible outcome.

Contact the Law Offices of Jason Bassett, P.C. today at (631) 259-6060 to schedule a consultation and take the first step towards protecting your rights and building a robust defense. Your peace of mind and future depend on it.

Free Consultation

If you didnt find an answer

Free consultation, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week

Call Now Button