Can Charges Be Dropped at Arraignment?

Last updated on August 7, 2024

Arraignment is the first official court hearing in a criminal case, where charges are formally read to the defendant and a plea is entered. This crucial step sets the stage for the legal process that follows. It also serves as an early opportunity for defense strategies to take shape, potentially influencing the outcome of the case. On Long Island, understanding the arraignment process is essential for anyone facing criminal charges, as it’s at this point that legal representation can make a significant impact.

Having a Long Island criminal defense attorney with extensive courtroom experience such as Jason Bassett can be indispensable. Mr. Bassett’s familiarity with the local courts and his adept handling of arraignment procedures provide crucial support to defendants. He works diligently to advocate for his clients, aiming to secure the best possible outcomes right from the outset of the case.

The importance of a well-prepared approach to arraignments cannot be overstated, especially when the potential for altering the course of a legal battle is highest at this early stage. Mr. Bassett advocates for those facing felony, misdemeanor, and violations across Long Island, including Suffolk County and Nassau County. If you are accused of a crime, it’s crucial to act quickly. Contact us today to schedule a complimentary and confidential consultation at (631) 259-6060.

What is an Arraignment?

Arraignment is the first court appearance for a person charged with a crime. During this hearing, the accused is formally informed of the charges against them and asked to enter a plea. In New York, the pleas available are “guilty” or “not guilty.” Under most circumstances, the arraignment must occur within 24 hours of arrest. The judge may also decide on bail or release conditions and set dates for future hearings, such as preliminary hearings or pre-trial motions.

This hearing is not just a formality; it is a pivotal moment in criminal proceedings where significant decisions regarding bail and release conditions are made. It also sets deadlines for prosecutorial actions and defense motions, laying the groundwork for pre-trial preparations.

Who Are Involved in an Arraignment?

Several key figures play critical roles during the arraignment process in Long Island:

  • The Accused: The individual facing criminal charges, whose rights and future are directly impacted by the hearing’s outcome.
  • Defense Attorney: Represents the accused, advising them on their rights, helping interpret the charges, and negotiating bail or other conditions of release. 
  • Prosecutor: A representative from the district attorney’s office who presents the charges and argues on behalf of the state regarding issues like bail and the need for Orders of Protection.
  • Judge: Presides over the hearing, ensures legal procedures are followed, decides on bai and whether protective orders are issued, and schedules further proceedings.
Who Are Involved in an Arraignment Hearing? Description
The Accused The individual facing criminal charges, whose rights and future are directly impacted by the hearing’s outcome.
Defense Attorney Represents the accused, advises on rights, helps interpret charges, and negotiates bail or other conditions of release.
Prosecutor Represents the district attorney’s office, presents charges, and argues on behalf of the state regarding bail and orders.
Judge Presides over the hearing, ensures legal procedures are followed, decides on bail, and schedules further proceedings.

What Happens During an Arraignment?

The arraignment process in Long Island follows a structured set of procedures to ensure fairness and legality:

Copy of Charges Provided 

The Court provides the accused with a copy of the charges against them.  While you have the right to have the charges against read aloud at the arraignment, as a matter of course the defense attorney will waive a reading of the charges and instead accepts a copy of the document outlining the charges, commonly referred to as a criminal complaint.

This criminal complaint details the specific charges and the relevant criminal laws that are alleged to have been broken. It also includes the facts needed to substantiate these charges. Generally, a police officer signs this document under oath, affirming its accuracy.

Entering a Plea

The accused responds to the charges by entering a plea, in almost all circumstances the plea is “Not Guilty.”

Bail Determination: For some charges, the judge can order the accused held unless they can post cash bail or a bail bond.  Factors influencing the decision as to whether to require bail and if so in what amount include the severity of the crime, the defendant’s criminal history, ties to the community, and risk of flight.  For other charges, an accused cannot be held on bail and must be released, either on their own recognizance or subject to the Supervised Release Program.

Order of Protection:  Depending on the nature of the alleged crime, the prosecutor may request an Order of Protection on behalf of the alleged victim.

Setting Next Court Date:  The case is adjourned for additional proceedings. 

Understanding these procedures helps those accused of crimes in Long Island prepare for their arraignment and make informed decisions about their defense strategy. With the assistance of a knowledgeable defense attorney, the accused can navigate this initial stage with a clearer sense of their legal options and rights.

Can Charges Be Dropped at Arraignment?

In New York, it is extremely rare for charges to be dropped at arraignment. While there are instances where charges might be reduced or dismissed early in the legal process, this is not common practice during the arraignment itself. The decision to drop charges typically involves a thorough review of the evidence, which usually occurs later, often after discussions between the defense and the prosecution or following further investigation.

Therefore, defendants should not expect charges to be dismissed during an arraignment. Instead, this initial court appearance sets the stage for the subsequent phases of the legal process, where more substantive arguments and evidence will be considered. This further highlights the importance of working with an experienced criminal defense attorney who can represent your rights at each stage of the process. Your attorney can guide you through each step and provide crucial insight regarding the legal procedures involved, helping you make an informed decision regarding the aspects of your case.

Is Arraignment the Same as a Trial?

An arraignment and a trial are two distinct stages in the criminal justice process, each serving different purposes and involving different procedures. Understanding the differences between these two stages is crucial for anyone navigating the legal system.

As mentioned, an arraignment is the first formal court appearance for a defendant after being charged with a crime. Your arraignment is distinct from your trial. Unlike a trial, the primary focus of an arraignment is to address preliminary matters following your arrest. No witnesses, evidence, or testimonies need to be presented during arraignment. This initial court appearance sets the stage for the subsequent steps in the legal process.

A trial, in contrast, is a thorough examination of the evidence and arguments presented by both the prosecution and the defense. The main purpose of a trial is to see if the prosecution can prove the defendant guilty of the charge(s) beyond a reasonable doubt (if a defendant is found guilty, the judge will schedule a separate date for sentencing). During a trial, both sides present are given the opportunity to present evidence, call witnesses, cross examine the other sides witnesses, and argue their case to a jury (or, in some circumstances, the judge). The trial concludes either with a verdict, where the defendant is either acquitted or convicted based on the evidence presented, or a “hung jury” (which is when the jury cannot come to an unanimous verdict of “guilty” or “not guilty”).

A common misconception is that an arraignment is a mini-trial or that it can result in the immediate dismissal of charges. However, this is not the case. Instead, the arraignment is a preliminary step in the criminal justice process, laying the groundwork for the trial or other resolutions such as plea bargains.

What Factors Can Affect the Outcome of an Arraignment?

The outcome of an arraignment in New York can significantly impact the defendant’s experience as their case progresses through the criminal justice system. Several factors influence the judge’s decisions during this initial hearing, particularly regarding bail, release conditions, and scheduling future court dates.

Nature and Severity of the Charges

One of the most critical factors affecting the outcomes of an arraignment is the nature and severity of the charges. More serious charges, such as violent felonies or high-level drug offenses, are likely to result in stricter conditions, including higher bail amounts or detention without bail. Conversely, less severe charges, such as misdemeanors or non-violent offenses, might lead to more lenient release conditions.

Defendant’s Criminal History

A defendant’s prior criminal record plays a significant role in the judge’s decisions at an arraignment. A history of previous convictions, especially for similar offenses, can result in higher bail or pretrial detention. On the other hand, a clean or minimal criminal record may favor the defendant, potentially leading to release on their own recognizance or lower bail.

Flight Risk

The judge will assess the likelihood of the defendant appearing for future court dates, often referred to as flight risk. Factors such as the defendant’s ties to the community, including family, employment, and residence stability, are considered. A defendant with strong community ties is viewed as less likely to flee, which might result in more favorable release conditions. In contrast, a defendant with minimal community ties or a history of failing to appear in court may face higher bail or detention.

Defense and Prosecution Arguments

Both the defense attorney and the prosecutor present arguments that can influence the judge’s decisions. The defense may argue for leniency based on factors like the defendant’s character, community ties, and any mitigating circumstances surrounding the alleged offense. The prosecutor, on the other hand, may highlight the severity of the charges, any potential risk to public safety, and the defendant’s criminal history. The judge weighs these arguments when determining release conditions and bail amounts.

Availability of Bail Resources

The defendant’s financial resources can also affect the outcome of an arraignment. If the judge sets bail, the amount must be something the defendant can realistically pay. Judges may consider the defendant’s ability to pay when setting bail to avoid unnecessary pretrial detention due to financial inability.

Having competent legal representation can significantly impact the outcome of an arraignment. A skilled defense attorney can effectively argue for release without bail, favorable release conditions, or at least bail that their client can afford. The attorney’s ability to present a compelling case for the defendant’s release can sway the judge’s decisions.

What Happens After Arraignment?

After the arraignment in New York, the criminal case can take several paths, depending on whether the charge is a misdemeanor or a felony. Your attorney will represent you throughout this process, helping you understand each step and advocating on your behalf.

If you are charged with a misdemeanor, the case moves forward with various motions and hearings. These pre-trial activities might include discovery motions, where both sides exchange evidence, and suppression hearings, which determine whether certain evidence can be used at trial. During this time, your attorney might negotiate with the prosecution to reach a plea agreement. A plea agreement can result in a reduced charge or a lighter sentence. If no agreement is reached, the case will go to trial, where a judge or jury or jury will decide whether or not the prosecution proved the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The trial ends with a verdict, a decision whether you are guilty or not guilty, or a mistrial due to the jury not being able to come to a unanimous verdict (a “hung jury”). If you are found guilty, the judge will then determine your sentence at a later time.

For felony charges, the process involves additional steps. After the initial arraignment, the case is presented to a grand jury, which reviews the evidence to decide if there is enough reason to proceed with the charges. If the grand jury indicts, the case then moves to the County Court or Supreme Court for another arraignment. At this County Court or Supreme Court arraignment, you will again be informed of the charges and asked to enter a plea.

Role of the Defense Attorney During Arraignment

In New York, especially on Long Island in Suffolk County and Nassau County, the defense attorney plays a crucial role during the arraignment process. This initial court appearance sets the groundwork for the entire legal proceeding, making the attorney’s involvement essential from the outset.

Pre-Arraignment Preparation

Before the arraignment, the defense attorney thoroughly reviews the charges and the accompanying evidence. This preparation includes analyzing the criminal complaint, understanding the alleged violations of law, and identifying any immediate concerns that need to be addressed. By doing so, the attorney can formulate an initial strategy and prepare the defendant for what to expect during the arraignment.

Advising the Defendant

During the arraignment, the defense attorney will advise the defendant on their rights and the charges they face. This guidance includes explaining the nature of the allegations, the potential consequences, and the legal options available, ensuring the defendant can make informed decisions.

Setting the Stage for Future Defense

The arraignment is also a critical moment for setting the stage for the future defense. The defense attorney may address issues such as bail and conditions of release, arguing for terms that are favorable to the defendant. Additionally, the attorney begins to lay the groundwork for any pre-trial motions or defenses that might be raised later in the process.

Having an experienced defense attorney during the arraignment is vital. An attorney with a deep understanding of New Jersey’s legal system can navigate the procedural nuances and advocate effectively on behalf of the defendant. This early intervention can significantly impact the trajectory of the case, highlighting the importance of skilled legal representation from the start.

On Long Island, the ability of a defense attorney to effectively advocate for their client during this early stage can significantly influence the trajectory of the case. It’s during the arraignment that key decisions about bail, release, and the immediate future of the legal process are made. With a legal professional like Jason Bassett by your side, you can approach this critical juncture with a well-prepared strategy, tailored to address the specifics of your case and enhance the chances of a favorable outcome. If you are facing criminal accusations, it’s important to act quickly. Contact Criminal Attorney Jason Bassett today at (631) 259-6060.

Free Consultation

If you didnt find an answer

Free consultation, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week